Where competing expert hypotheses as to the cause of an accident are advanced, the plaintiff must establish a 'definite conclusion affirmatively drawn' as to causation; it is not sufficient that the evidence gives rise to conflicting inferences of equal probability. Causative negligence must be proved on the theory of causation established — even if the plaintiff's theory of causation were accepted, the plaintiff must still prove that a reasonable person would have taken steps that would have avoided the accident. A late application to amend particulars of negligence to allege a new basis of fault will be refused where the plaintiff's own expert had previously disclaimed that basis, no explanation for the delay is provided, and the proposed particulars lack evidentiary support.
The full text is available to signed-in members, including the 1 later case that cites this judgment.