In a negligence case depending on circumstantial evidence, the plaintiff bears the onus of excluding alternative hypotheses of equal or greater probability; it is not for the defendant to negative reasonable possibilities. Where the primary judge's finding depends on an inference that a CSA failed to observe a protruding body, but the evidence equally supports the hypothesis that no significant protrusion occurred, the plaintiff's case fails. A party that does not seek an adjournment or other indulgence in response to a supposedly late formulation of the opposing case is bound by that forensic decision and cannot raise procedural fairness on appeal.
The full text is available to signed-in members, including the 2 later cases that cite this judgment.