The mitigating factors arising from an offender's mental illness (reduced moral culpability, inappropriateness as vehicle for general deterrence, and heavier burden of custody) may be entirely negated by the countervailing consideration that the offender poses a danger to the community. The Hemsley factors do not operate as automatic discounts; they are considerations that may balance out against each other. For aggregate sentences, it is the aggregate that must be shown to be manifestly excessive, not merely an individual indicative component.
The full text is available to signed-in members, including the 1 later case that cites this judgment.