Where the Crown disclaims reliance on admissions or consciousness of guilt reasoning from pretext call evidence but then asserts in closing address that the call contains truthful admissions from which the accused lied in court, the trial judge must enquire whether the Crown seeks to withdraw its earlier concession and, if lies are relied upon, require the Crown to identify the specific admissions and lies. Failure to give an [name withheld] or [name withheld] direction in such circumstances will occasion a miscarriage of justice where there is a real risk the jury misunderstood the permissible use of the evidence.
The full text is available to signed-in members.