Comparable cases and Judicial Commission sentencing statistics are of limited utility in demonstrating manifest excess where the applicant's criminal history and circumstances at the time of offending (particularly being on parole for a like offence) are materially different from the comparators relied upon. A sentence with a starting point of approximately 4 years and 8 months for supply of 42.95g of methylamphetamine by an offender on parole for a like offence, with an entrenched drug history and multiple prior drug convictions, was within range notwithstanding findings of low objective seriousness and a strong subjective case.
The full text is available to signed-in members.