Where an offender is convicted of a specially aggravated form of an offence (here, kidnapping in company with actual bodily harm under s 86(3) Crimes Act 1900) and a co-offender is convicted of the aggravated form (s 86(2)(a)), the sentencing judge may properly take into account both the higher maximum penalty and the offender's greater role in the offending without engaging in impermissible double-counting. A 50% difference in head sentences may be justified by differences in the statutory offences, roles in the offending, and subjective circumstances.
The full text is available to signed-in members.