The majority reaffirmed that an appellate court should not determine an unreasonable verdict appeal on the basis of a defence that was never raised at trial, in the grounds of appeal, or in argument, and was raised for the first time by the court itself. The dissent raises the question whether, in sexual offence cases where the complainant remains passive and does not communicate non-consent, the circumstantial evidence may be insufficient to prove knowledge of non-consent beyond reasonable doubt under s 61HE(3), even where the physical acts are proved. The question of whether an appellate court may independently assess the sufficiency of evidence on an uncharged element (knowledge of non-consent) that was not the focus of the defence case remains contested.
The full text is available to signed-in members.