The Court held that a contractual recourse clause requiring the principal to be 'acting reasonably' in asserting breach and claiming costs operates as a 'risk allocation device' entitling the principal to call on unconditional bank guarantees at an early stage of a dispute, without needing to definitively establish breach or quantum. The Court confirmed, following John Holland v RTA, Patterson Building, Fabtech and Acciona, that an adjudication determination under SOPA does not stand in the way of a principal exercising contractual rights to have recourse to security, as s 34 of SOPA does not render void contractual provisions for recourse to security where the adjudicated amount has been paid and the Act has operated according to its terms. The contractor failed to discharge its onus of establishing a serious question to be tried that the principal was not acting reasonably, and the balance of convenience favoured the principal given the contractual allocation of risk.
The full text is available to signed-in members, including the 5 later cases that cite this judgment.