The Commission found that the applicant sustained a compensable psychological injury in the course of employment, with employment being the main contributing factor under s 4(b)(i) of the Workers Compensation Act 1987. The respondent's expert opinion attributing the condition to stress about a non-work-related pulmonary embolism was rejected as inconsistent with contemporaneous treating evidence uniformly pointing to workplace stressors including perceived excessive workload and lack of support. The s 11A(1) defence based on performance appraisal failed because the respondent's own expert did not clearly opine that performance appraisal was the whole or predominant cause, instead attributing the condition to both performance appraisal and other management actions such as task allocation, and the treating evidence did not support performance appraisal as the predominant cause.
The full text is available to signed-in members.