1A party asserting an offsetting claim to set aside a statutory demand must adduce evidence disclosing a rational basis for the quantification of that claim; the mere assertion of estimated rectification costs by a company director, without any stated methodology, underlying reasoning, or identification of actual costs incurred, is insufficient to permit the court to quantify the claim and will result in only nominal value being attributed to it.
2Where rectification works have been completed but the applicant leads no evidence of the actual costs incurred — and where other claimed defects have not been rectified, have been rectified by the creditor, or are no longer required — the failure to adjust the offsetting claim to reflect these developments further undermines its quantification.
3A company that adopts adverse third-party expert reports as true in statutory demand proceedings to establish defects will likely be bound by those admissions in subsequent proceedings brought by those third parties, on abuse of process grounds.