1A dispute or offsetting claim that is merely a 'constructed response' to the pressure of a creditor's statutory demand, rather than one raised bona fide and in good faith, is not 'genuine' for the purposes of s 459H of the Corporations Act, applying Creata (Aust) Pty Ltd v [name withheld] and Grandview Ausbuilder Pty Ltd v Budget Demolitions Pty Ltd.
2On the facts, the absence of contemporaneous notification of alleged defects or delay claims prior to service of the demand, the director's failure to give evidence of actual dissatisfaction with the works, and the acknowledged cessation of lift incidents months before the demand was served, demonstrated that the disputes and offsetting claims were constructed rather than genuine.
3A [name withheld] offer that requires releases extending beyond the scope of the proceedings does not render it unreasonable for the offeree to reject the offer, and therefore does not support an indemnity costs order.