Discharge, Breach and Defences to Action for Breach
Performance
Quick Take
1A service contract's obligation to remotely monitor equipment and 'proactively initiate service action' for potential issues (preventative maintenance) is not engaged where monitoring reveals an actual existing malfunction. That falls within corrective maintenance, which, on the proper construction of this agreement, was limited to the agreed service window hours unless the customer requested chargeable out-of-hours service. Sending automated alerts to the customer satisfied any monitoring obligation.
2Applying Bryan v Moloney, Astley v Austrust and Brookfield Multiplex, where a detailed contract completely and exclusively defines what services are provided, when, and at what price, no concurrent tortious duty arises requiring the service provider to act beyond or inconsistently with those terms. Such a duty would alter the contractual allocation of risk and give the customer a benefit it had not paid for.
3Whether a representation is misleading is assessed objectively from the position of a reasonable representee (Krakowski v Eurolynx). On the facts, a post-repair statement that a system 'fully meets specifications and is returned to use' conveyed that the machine was operational with no physical evidence of a continuing defect, not that it was free of latent internal damage. Separately, a supplier owes no duty to recommend replacing a major component before the cause of repeated failures has been reasonably investigated, including ruling out environmental factors.
Case Details
Citation[2025] QSC 317
CourtQSC
JurisdictionQueensland
Unlock so much more with Barrister AI
The full text is available to signed-in members, including the 1 later case that cites this judgment.