The Court held that a tiered dispute resolution clause containing the word 'may' in relation to serving a notice of dispute, combined with mandatory language requiring compliance with the dispute resolution procedures, does not confer an option to litigate rather than arbitrate — the permissive language merely reflects the option to acquiesce or pursue the dispute. The Court further held that an arbitration agreement is not 'inoperative' under s 8(1) of the Commercial Arbitration Act 2013 (Qld) merely because preliminary steps in a tiered dispute resolution clause have not yet been completed, expressly declining to follow [name withheld] in John Holland and Broken Hill City Council and instead adopting the reasoning of [name withheld] in WCX M4-M5 and [name withheld] in Siam Steel. The Court also held that where a dispute notice clause covers disputes arising 'out of or in connection with' the agreement, the narrower phrase 'dispute under the agreement' in a condition precedent clause should be read as shorthand for the broader formulation, encompassing non-contractual claims including negligence and ACL claims.
The full text is available to signed-in members.