1Under Schedule 2 item 23(a) of the Bail Act 1977 (Vic), a person accused of an indictable offence is subject to the compelling reason test where another person involved in the offence is alleged to have used an offensive weapon (as defined in s 77(1A) of the Crimes Act 1958 (Vic)), even if the accused did not personally use it.
2On the facts, a compelling reason was established by the combination of several matters: the 'extremely onerous' (solitary) conditions of remand previously acknowledged by the Court of Appeal; a real risk that pre-trial remand of up to two years would exceed any sentence; likely triable issues about complicity for assaults committed by co-accused; newly available stable accommodation; and young children needing care.
3On the facts, the prosecution's burden of proving unacceptable risk under s 4E was not discharged, because the risk could be mitigated by several matters: strict geographic exclusion conditions directed at the public settings in which the alleged offending arose; non-association with co-accused; the added consequences of breaching an existing community correction order; a substantial third-party bail guarantee; and a long, though imperfect, record of reporting and attendance compliance. The court gave reduced weight to the opinion of an informant who was not fully conversant with the applicant's circumstances and history.