APPEAL — from findings of fact — challenge to trial judge’s finding as to nature of information required by local council — appellant bore burden of demonstrating that finding was wrong — burden not discharged
LEASES AND TENANCIES — default and termination — commercial lease — express right to terminate if occupation certificate not obtained by contractual deadline — implied limitation preventing party from relying on own breach or default — construction of lease not challenged on appeal — whether lessee entitled to terminate
CONTRACTS — performance — discharge by performance — lessee required to provide all information required for Council expeditiously to process development application — Council requested “BCA report for a fit out” — whether request required clause-by-clause assessment of proposed fit-out and existing building — purpose of BCA compliance report — absence of express statutory requirement immaterial — obligation to seek clarification if request ambiguous — breach established
CONTRACTS — causation — material contribution — substantial chance — whether outstanding fire safety order caused requirement for BCA compliance report or material delay — no causal connection established — other requests for information concerned minor matters capable of prompt and concurrent resolution — statutory period allowed by Council for response did not qualify contractual obligation to act expeditiously
Quick Take
1Where a commercial lease confers a mutual right to terminate if a condition (here, obtaining an occupation certificate by a deadline) is not met, an implied limitation prevents a party from invoking that right where its own breach of contractual obligations materially contributed to the non-fulfilment of the condition; the construction of Art 29(9) was not challenged on appeal.
2A council's requirement to provide a 'BCA report' with a development application for fit-out and change of use of premises in an existing building is, objectively construed by reference to the purpose of enabling the consent authority to discharge its obligations under s 64(2) of the EPA Regulation, a requirement for a clause-by-clause assessment of compliance of both the proposed works and the existing building with the BCA; alternatively, if the requirement is ambiguous, the lessee's contractual obligation to act expeditiously requires it to seek clarification.
3On the facts, the requirement to provide a BCA compliance report arose independently of an outstanding fire safety order affecting the building, and the lessee failed to demonstrate that the fire safety order caused the council to impose the requirement or independently contributed to the delay in obtaining development consent.