APPEALS — application for leave to appeal — appeal from decision summarily dismissing proceedings under Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005 (NSW) r 13.4 — no question of general principle, public importance, or error amounting to a reasonably clear injustice going beyond what is merely arguable
Quick Take
1A release clause in a deed of settlement bars later proceedings where the subject matter of the new proceedings 'relates to' the subject matter of the settled proceedings, even where the new proceedings involve different classes of proceedings, different statutory instruments, or post-deed evidence, provided the underlying legal and factual controversy is the same as that specially in the contemplation of the parties at the time of the release.
2A council's assessment and refusal of a building information certificate application under Division 6.7 of Part 6 of the EP&A Act does not constitute 'enforcement action' within the meaning of a deed restricting enforcement action under Part 9 of the Act, as the BIC process is an administrative certification function, not a compulsion of obedience to planning laws.
3Where an applicant has sold the property that is the subject of the dispute, the absence of utility in the proposed appeal weighs heavily against the grant of leave, and the fact that the appeal would at most affect costs does not, except in the most compelling case, engage any issue of principle, public importance, or reasonably clear injustice.