The Court held that a submission seeking sentencing reduction for onerous COVID-19 custody conditions must be supported by evidence establishing the specific adverse consequences experienced by the offender; the mere assertion of COVID-19's existence is insufficient, and a sentencing judge is not obliged to provide notice of an intention to reject an unsupported submission advanced by only one party. On parity, the Court held that express use of the word 'parity' is not required where the sentencing reasons disclose a comparative analysis of co-offenders' culpability, and that significant differences in role and Form 1 offending precluded a justifiable sense of grievance. On [name withheld], the Court held that a 'rather unhappy childhood' involving parental separation and loss of a grandparent, but with ongoing family support, does not reach the level of deprivation necessary to engage the [name withheld] principles regarding reduced moral culpability, and that absent submissions on the point, no general obligation exists for a sentencing judge to consider [name withheld] of its own motion unless the case for deprivation is overwhelming.
The full text is available to signed-in members.