The Court held that WHS Act proceedings are not an abuse of process merely because a defendant has already been convicted and sentenced under the Food Act for offences arising from the same incident, where the offences have substantially different elements, address different aspects of criminality, and are imposed under different legislative schemes with different protective purposes. Any overlap in underlying conduct can be addressed through evidentiary rulings (including exclusion of admissions under s 90 of the Evidence Act) and through the sentencing exercise, rather than requiring a permanent stay. The Court also confirmed that compliance with prosecutorial guidelines and the public interest assessment are matters for the independent prosecutor, not the court, absent evidence of impropriety.
The full text is available to signed-in members.