TREES (DISPUTES BETWEEN NEIGHBOURS) — Pt 2 application — neighbouring tree — whether the tree has caused damage — concrete pavement — terracotta sewer and stormwater pipes — whether roots found in pipes are from the subject tree — proposed consent orders — whether compensation should be ordered — orders for tree removal
Quick Take
1Proposed consent orders in a Trees Act application will only be made if they are orders the Court can and would make. The Court may decline an agreed compensation order where the s 10(2) jurisdictional threshold is not met for part of the claimed damage, or where s 12 considerations weigh against it (Breen v Caronna [2008] NSWLEC 293 applied).
2On the facts, roots found in pipes that were neither identified (visually or by DNA) nor traced to the subject tree did not establish that the subject tree caused the pipe damage, particularly where another tree not the subject of the application was equally or more proximate. Arborists' unsupported assumptions as to root origin were insufficient.
3Under s 12(h) and (j), compensation may be refused where: damage likely pre-dated the applicants' purchase; the tree owner had no knowledge of the damage before notification and so was not adopting or continuing a known cause of damage; and aged terracotta pipes contributed to root ingress. Damage from leaf and debris blockage of gutters is ordinarily a matter of property maintenance (Barker v Kyriakides [2007] NSWLEC 292 at [20]).