CIVIL PROCEDURE — freezing orders — where plaintiff seeks freezing order over moneys held by the second defendant in the sum of $12m — where second defendant sold its substantive asset for $20m — where second defendant intends to utilise sale proceeds by making intercompany loans to related entities — where danger that prospective judgment will be unsatisfied due to disposal of assets — where quantum of freezing order based on evidence of loss which lacks underlying reasoning and which is based on sums not yet claimed — freezing order in the sum of $12m ordered over proceeds of sale held in the second defendant’s bank account — liberty to apply to reduce sum if quantity surveyor’s evidence departs downwards from provisional estimated loss and applicant does not claim the asserted losses within a reasonable time
Quick Take
1A danger that a prospective judgment will be unsatisfied under UCPR r 25.14(4) may be shown where a trustee company with no ongoing trade or existing debts holds substantial cash proceeds and intends to deploy them for the benefit of related group companies by intercompany loan or otherwise. This is distinguished from using funds to discharge the company's own debts, following Aqualand and Golden Rain.
2Where quantum evidence is provisional, the court may fix an interim monetary limit by evaluative assessment. On the facts, components resting on unreasoned expert estimates, unpleaded variations and full indemnity costs justified a rounded $12m limit. That limit reduces presumptively if expert evidence departs downwards or the variations are not claimed within a reasonable time, with the onus then on the applicant to justify a higher figure.
3An owners corporation's negative net asset position does not necessarily undermine its undertaking as to damages, given its statutory capacity to raise levies from lot owners. A respondent's offer to restrain only real property of uncertain value may be insufficient where that value falls well short of the likely claim.