City Edge South Melbourne Holdings Pty Ltd v Dehou Capital Pty Ltd atf the Leong Investment Unit Trust [2026] VSC 671 — Injunctions & Landlord And Tenant — Barrister AI
City Edge South Melbourne Holdings Pty Ltd v Dehou Capital Pty Ltd atf the Leong Investment Unit Trust
› Landlord's repair and maintenance obligations — effect of breach on right to terminate
Real Property
› Landlord and Tenant
› Dispute resolution clauses — scope of stay on enforcement
Quick Take
1Where a landlord holds an express accrued contractual right to terminate a lease for non-payment of rent, the tenant seeking to restrain termination must establish not merely that the landlord is in breach of its own lease obligations, but that the landlord's right to terminate has not arisen or that there is some equitable or legal basis preventing its exercise; a breach of repair and maintenance obligations does not of itself extinguish or suspend the landlord's termination right.
2A dispute resolution clause providing that no party may 'commence or maintain any action' until expert determination is complete does not operate as a quasi-injunction restraining a landlord from issuing default notices or terminating a lease; 'action' in that context refers to legal proceedings, and a tenant's obligation to pay rent is independent of a dispute about the landlord's maintenance obligations.
3A lease clause requiring a landlord not to unreasonably withhold consent to acts by the tenant requiring consent under the lease does not oblige the landlord to become a party to a tripartite deed with the tenant's lender that would impose new obligations on the landlord and fetter the landlord's contractual rights, particularly where the tenant is in substantial default.