Deductive (contemporary sales) value
161C Deductive (contemporary sales) value
The deductive (contemporary sales) value of imported goods is their value calculated as if the value of each of their units were the unit price of comparable goods sold in the reference sale or sales.
In this section:
contemporary sale, in relation to comparable goods comparable with imported goods, means a sale known to a Collector of the comparable goods in Australia in the condition in which they were imported, being a sale:
at about the same time as the time of importation of the imported goods;
at the first trade level at which the comparable goods were sold after their importation;
in circumstances where, in the opinion of the Collector, the purchaser of the comparable goods:
was not, at the time of the sale, related to the vendor of the comparable goods; and
did not incur any production assist costs in relation to the comparable goods; and
that was, in the opinion of the Collector, a sale of a sufficient number of units of comparable goods as to permit an appropriate determination of their price per unit.
reference sale, in relation to comparable goods, means:
where there was only one contemporary sale of the goods—that sale;
where:
there were 2 or more such sales; and
the comparable goods were sold in those sales at the one unit price;
each of those sales;
where:
there were 2 or more such sales;
the comparable goods were sold in those sales at 2 or more unit prices; and
a higher number of units of comparable goods were sold in those sales at one of those unit price than were sold in those sales at any other single particular unit price;
the sale, or each of the sales, in which comparable goods were sold at the particular unit price first‑mentioned in subparagraph (iii);
where:
there were 2 or more such sales;
the comparable goods were sold in those sales at 2 or more unit prices; and
an equal number of units of comparable goods were sold in those sales at each of those unit prices;
the sale or sales in which the comparable goods were sold at the lower or lowest of the unit prices; and
where:
there were 2 or more such sales;
the comparable goods were sold in those sales at 2 or more unit prices; and
an equal number of units of comparable goods were sold in those sales at 2 or more of those unit prices and that number was not exceeded by the number of units of comparable goods sold in those sales at any other single particular unit price;
the sale, or sales, at which comparable goods were sold at the lower or lowest of the unit prices first‑mentioned in subparagraph (iii).
unit price, in relation to comparable goods sold in a contemporary sale, means the price of the goods in that sale:
reduced by the sum of value unrelated amounts, deductible administrative costs, and deductible financing costs, in relation to the comparable goods; and
divided by the number of units of the comparable goods.
The following example illustrates the operation of paragraph (c) of the definition of reference sale in subsection (2):
Facts:
There were 2 contemporary sales of 5 units of comparable goods at a unit price of $100.
There were 6 contemporary sales of 3 units of comparable goods at a unit price of $40.
There was one contemporary sale of 4 units of comparable goods at a unit price of $40.
There was one contemporary sale of 7 units of comparable goods at a unit price of $60.
There were 3 contemporary sales of 2 units of comparable goods at a unit price of $60.
This means that:
10 units of comparable goods were sold in contemporary sales at $100.
22 units of comparable goods were sold in contemporary sales at $40.
13 units of comparable goods were sold in contemporary sales at $60.
Result:
More units of comparable goods were sold in contemporary sales at $40 than were sold in such sales at any other unit price.
Therefore, the reference sales are the sales at the unit price of $40.
The following example illustrates the operation of paragraph (e) of the definition of reference sale in subsection (2):
Facts:
There was one contemporary sale of 10 units of comparable goods at a unit price of $60.
There were 2 contemporary sales of 2 units of comparable goods at a unit price of $20.
There was one contemporary sale of 6 units of comparable goods at a unit price of $20.
There were 8 contemporary sales of 1 unit of comparable goods at a unit price of $80.
There was one contemporary sale of 5 units of comparable goods at a unit price of $70.
There were 2 contemporary sales of 2 units of comparable goods at a unit price of $70.
There were 2 contemporary sales of 1 unit of comparable goods at a unit price of $50.
There were 2 contemporary sales of 4 units of comparable goods at a unit price of $50.
Result:
An equal number of units of comparable goods (10) were sold in contemporary sales at 3 unit prices ($60, $20, $50).
This number is not exceeded by 8 units of comparable goods sold in contemporary sales at $80 or by 9 units of comparable goods sold in contemporary sales at $70.
Therefore, reference sales are the sales at the unit price of $20.
The statute text is free to read above. View subscription options to unlock the case-law research tools for each provision.