Reasonableness of hypothesis to be assessed by reference to Statement of Principles
338 Reasonableness of hypothesis to be assessed by reference to Statement of Principles
This section applies to a claim under section 319 for acceptance of liability under subsection 23(1) or 24(1) for an injury, disease or death (other than an injury, disease or death covered by subparagraph 27(c)(i), paragraph 27(da) or (e), subparagraph 28(1)(c)(i) or paragraph 28(1)(ea) or (f)) that relates to warlike service, non‑warlike service, British nuclear test defence service or hazardous service.
Subsections 335(1) and (2) are relevant to these claims.
If the Authority has given notice under section 370CJ that it intends to carry out an investigation in respect of a particular kind of injury, disease or death:
the Commission is not to determine a claim for acceptance of liability for a person’s injury, disease or death of that kind; and
the Commission, the Board or the Tribunal is not to make a decision on the reconsideration or review of:
a determination by the Commission on such a claim; or
such a determination as previously affirmed or varied; or
a decision made on a previous review in substitution for a determination referred to in subparagraph (i) or (ii);
unless or until the Authority:
has determined a Statement of Principles under section 370CB in respect of that kind of injury, disease or death; or
has declared that it does not propose to determine such a Statement of Principles.
Subsection (2) does not apply if the presumption in subsection 27A(1) or (2) is relied on for the purposes of determining the claim or making a decision on the reconsideration or review of a determination relating to the claim.
Subsections 27A(1) and (2) contain a presumption that certain injuries and diseases are attributable to defence service unless the contrary is established.
For the purposes of subsection 335(2), a hypothesis connecting an injury sustained, or a disease contracted, by a person, or the death of a person, with the circumstances of any particular service rendered by the person while a member, is reasonable only if there is in force:
a Statement of Principles determined under section 370CB or subsection 370CN(1); or
a determination of the Commission under subsection 340(2) of this Act;
that upholds the hypothesis.
See subsection (4) about the application of this subsection.
Subsection (3) does not apply in relation to a claim for acceptance of liability for a person’s injury, disease or death if the Authority has neither determined a Statement of Principles under section 370CB, nor declared that it does not propose to make such a Statement of Principles, in respect of:
the kind of injury sustained by the person; or
the kind of disease contracted by the person; or
the kind of death met by the person;
as the case may be.
Sign in to see bill, explanatory material, and regulations and instruments
The statute text is free to read above. View subscription options to unlock the case-law research tools for each provision.