› Aggregate sentence — totality principle — improper to isolate one component
Criminal Law
› Sentencing
› Armed robbery — drug addiction as motive — moral culpability — R v [name withheld] guideline
Criminal Law
› Sentencing
› Shoot with intent to murder — objective seriousness — above mid-range
Quick Take
1In assessing whether a sentence for multiple offences, aggregate or otherwise, is excessive or inadequate, it is arbitrary to identify one component and treat the balance of the sentence as referable to all the other offences. Even if indicative sentences are lenient, that does not necessarily mean the aggregate sentence is manifestly inadequate. The principal focus is whether the aggregate reflects the totality of the criminality.
2Where a sentencing judge accepted an offender's sworn evidence of remorse, and the truthfulness of what he told a psychologist, and the Crown did not challenge that evidence below, it is not open to the Crown to attack those findings on appeal. Contentions not raised at first instance (here, that the robberies were committed partly for a 'thrill') should be disregarded.
3A sentencing judge's reliance on R v [name withheld] at [273](b)(iii) to find that offending was motivated by drug addiction rather than principally by greed involved no error, even where the offences were planned. On a Crown appeal the question is not whether the sentence is lenient but whether it is unreasonable or plainly unjust.
Case Details
Citation[2014] NSWCCA 331
CourtNSWCCA
JurisdictionNew South Wales
Unlock so much more with Barrister AI
The full text is available to signed-in members, including the 5 later cases that cite this judgment.
2 of the 5 citing cases carry a classified treatment. How each court treated it is available to signed-in members.